Sunday, January 20, 2008

A critical exploration of beautification vs truth in nude photography

http://www.dentphotography.co.za/page9/files/Nudity.pdf

Diesel: For Successful Living

http://www.dentphotography.co.za/page9/files/Semiotics.pdf

An exploration of the inter-personal relationships that exist between photographers and their models, with reference to portrait photographers

Portrait photography is the art of expressing the dynamics that exist between a model and photographer, in order to create an image that represents both the likeness of the model, as well as the photographer’s creative insight. By analysing the work of various photographers, it can be said that a spectrum of interpersonal dynamics exists between photographers and models, ranging from the photographer having complete control over the model, to the model being allowed full expressive freedom within a moment that is merely captured by the photographer. In order to illustrate the afore mentioned spectrum, works of Loretta Lux, Dianne Arbus, Richard Avedon, Sebastiao Saldago and Henri Cartier-Bresson will be discussed with reference to their approach to portrait photography. Through reviewing specific images, it will be possible to outline a range of expressive styles and basic dynamics that exist between portrait photographers and their models, and prove the hypothesis that this spectrum does indeed play a role in the creation of portraits.

Loretta Lux approaches her models with a sense of complete control. She uses children to pass social commentary on the ways that adults overlook the difficulties and insecurities faced by a child, and on the staticness of being with which society expects children to live. The work is narrative and focuses on the time in life that lies between the development of personal views and opinions, and the point at which those views are taken seriously but the adult world.

In order to portray her metaphors Loretta Lux treats her models as mere props, with no more emphasis placed on the model than any other element within the image. The children are unrecognisable for who they are, their eyes, skin and limbs graphically distorted to create static perfection. They are expressionless, caught mid-pose, mid-action and mid-thought, as seen in this image entitled “The Drummer” (online: http://www.lorettalux.de/). They are merely placed within a timeframe to mirror the time of life that she wishes to portray through her photographs.

The work has an illustrative quality and the models are subjected to much post-production and digital manipulation. As people, they are unimportant, but as graphic elements they are vital to the success of her work. It can be said that Loretta Lux exercises complete control over her models, and that the model is allowed no input into the portrait.

Dianne Arbus, like Lux, stages her models within the frame, yet places them in poses that appear natural and unposed, as seen in the image entitled “Triplets,” (online: HYPERLINK "http://www.artnet.com/artwork/424401554/424175658/triplets-in-their-bedroom.html" http://www.artnet.com/artwork/424401554/424175658/triplets-in-their-bedroom.html) in which three sisters sit alongside each other on a bed. They are posed to look as though the photographer merely found them there, interacting as sisters naturally do, yet the interaction between the models is static, and appears to be detached. There is a rigid use of graphic shape within the image, which is composed of three rectangular shapes, according to the rule of thirds, and symbolic of rigidity. The models appear to be detached from both each other and the photographer. Each holds an empty expression, and each with a unique point of focus within the room. The girl on the left looks just above the photographers’ head, the one in the middle to the left of the image, and the one on the right somewhere in between. There is a sense of vacancy within the frame, and a sense of posed detachedness that detracts from the naturalness of the scene of three sisters sitting together in their room that has been captured.

Although the three models have been captured in an intimate environment, being that of their bedroom, they are portrayed without individuality, and there appears to be no warmth between them, as though they are without interpersonal relationships or personality. They are photographed to appear natural, yet have no real input into the image – the appearance of the models and the styling of the image are controlled entirely by the photographer, yet she has created the illusion that the models have been photographed in a natural situation. By portraying the models as static and without a sense of real input, Arbus passes social commentary on the rigidity of the era, and on the rigidity with which women are handled by society; even in the most intimate of places, such as one’s own bedroom, the woman is expected to exercise self-control and keep up appearances. The appearance of naturalness between these women is not only restricted to that of social confines, but also to the control of the photographer in the manner in which they are portrayed by her. It can be said that, through doing this, Dianne Arbus creates an impression of the model she photographs, yet still exercises near complete control over the way in which the model is portrayed to the viewer.

Similarly to Dianne Arbus, Richard Avedon poses his models within a vision of what he would like to portray, yet in contrast, Avedon allows the camera to capture the uniqueness of the person being photographed, and the expressive quality that the model wishes to portray.

In his work entitled “Ronald Fisher: Beekeeper,” (online: http://www.richardavedon.com/#s=14&a=0&mi=2&pt=1&pi=10000&p=7&at=0) Avedon places the model in a position of clear discomfort. He is naked, and his skin is covered with bees which are clearly stinging him. The composition is clean and clinical with clean-cut lines, low contrasts and a predominantly high-key treatment. The model has been asked to keep still and stagnant, and to hold a rigid pose, yet his expression and body language are allowed to portray an emotive quality within the prescribed pose.

Tension is visible in his neck, the shoulders are slightly lifted and the muscles have a tense energy about them. The smile is somewhere between that of fear and internal contentment, and the eyes are direct and confrontational, yet the viewer is made aware of a certain level of distraction in the directness of the gaze, clearly due to the surrounding bees.

Richard Avedon allows the models’ natural reaction to his surroundings to be portrayed in the image, and, as a result, the viewer is taken on the models internal journey through the situation. An interesting juxtaposition is created between a fascination for the idea of the bees, curiosity for the pain of the stings, and an acceptance of the discomfort experienced by the model. Through doing this, Avedon portrays a unique tension between the fear of the situation, and the enjoyment of it, which is mimicked in the models strained yet content expression. This image is highly emotive, portraying a constant relationship between the positive and negative elements of what it represents, which has been achieved through Avedon and the model creating a balance between the photographer’s visual guidance and the model’s personal expression of the situation.

Where Avedon focuses on a balance between the visual and emotive qualities of his work, Sebastiao Saldago allows the emotive aspect of the model to surpass his photographic insight within his images, whilst maintaining a strong sense of visual foresight and careful planning. This can be seen in his image entitled “Gourma – Rharos, Mali, 1985,” (online: http://www.isaf.com.ar/Autores/Varios%20autor/imagenes%20SS/pages/1985%20Gourma%20%20Rharous_jpg.htm) a documentary portrait, The image has been carefully planned by Saldago and has a sense of simplicity in the circular composition and natural pose, yet it has been handled with a sense of sensitivity and carries a feeling of slow deliberation. Energy is created through the flowing lines of the hands and the drapery, yet the image captures quietness that has been portrayed by the model. The viewer is allowed transportation into the inner sanctity of the model, yet this is done within the clean-cut composition and the attention to detail and form that the photographer has treated the scene with.

The visual strength of this image is the emotive quality that the model evokes in the viewer, which is dominant in the photograph and merely complimented by the photographers use of line, texture and form. The image speaks of spirituality and emotional power, and is a representation of humanity. The viewer is reminded of honesty, and compassion through what the model portrays. This presents a stark contrast to Loretta Lux, as both comment on emotional reactions to life, yet Lux does so in a way that de-humanises her model, and Saldago does so by capturing a sense of humanity in his work. From this, it can be said that Sebastiao Saldago allows the model to portray his concept within a framework of visual guidance and photographic interpretation.

Loretta Lux places no importance on the individuality of her models, using them as mere elements within her image as a whole. Henri Cartier-Bresson plainly contrasts this approach in his work by capturing unstaged moments in time, and allowing his models to be represented with a sense of candid freedom. In his work entitled “Albert Camus, 1947,” (online: http://digitaljournalist.org/issue0408/howe-bresson.html) the model has been portrayed in a natural environment, and, although he is a famous writer he is represented as a normal person just walking down the street. The moment the model looked into the lens has been captured, creating an unposed and real depiction of the man being photographed.

Cartier-Bresson uses photographic tools such as lenses, high contrasts and natural lighting to add emotive value and visual interest to his images, yet he exercises no control over the way in which the person in the photograph chooses to portray himself. The viewer is offered a glimpse into the life of someone else, creating a direct connection between the model and the viewer. There is a strong sense of movement captured in the work, as though the model is about to walk away and out of the moment forever, yet he is preserved through the photographer having captured him.

In the work of Cartier-Bresson, the people he documents and photographs are shown as they would like to portray themselves. The only influence that the photographer has over the final image is that of his use of a camera and his treatment of the image in the darkroom. He uses these tools to enhance what the model portrays as opposed to using them to select certain aspects of the model that he would like the viewer to see. The model creates the final outcome of the image through personal expression, and the energy that is captured in a single moment in time.

From the above it is clear that a unique inter-personal relationship exists between all photographers and their models, and that a style spectrum can be used to describe these relationships. Loretta Lux allows her model no individuality or personal expression within her images, and shows a complete sense of control over her subjects, whereas, at the opposite extreme, Henri Cartier-Bresson displays no influence over his subject other than the photographic tools at his disposal, such as the speed of his film, the lens used or his exposure. Other photographers such as Dianne Arbus, Richard Avedon and Sebastiao Saldago blend their photographic insights with model individuality and social commentary in order to create images that are both conceptual and visually planned. In order for a portrait photographer to develop a unique style, it is important that he makes a conscious decision with regard to the handling of his models, and to the level of expressive freedom that he will allow the model to have within his creative vision for the final image. In doing this, the images captured will be a well-balanced blend between reality, emotive expression and graphic strength.



Bibliography

LUX (2007): Loretta Lux Photography, Official Site.
Retrieved on 23/10/2007 from the World Wide Web at
HYPERLINK "http://www.lorettalux.de/" http://www.lorettalux.de/

PINCH WHAT YOU LIKE (2004): Dianne Arbus, An Unofficial Website.
Retrieved on 23/10/2007 from the World Wide Web at
HYPERLINK "http://www.dianearbus.net/" http://www.dianearbus.net/

AVEDON FOUNDATION (date unknown): The Richard Avedon Foundation
Retrieved on 23/10/2007 from the World Wide Web at
HYPERLINK "http://www.richardavedon.com/" http://www.richardavedon.com/

EXPLORATORIUM (2002): Sebastiao Saldago Official Site
Retrieved on 23/10/2007 from the World Wide Web at
HYPERLINK "http://www.terra.com.br/sebastiaosalgado/" http://www.terra.com.br/sebastiaosalgado/

H.C.B FONDATION (date unknown): Fondation Henri Cartier-Bresson
Retrieved on 23/10/2007 from the World Wide Web at
HYPERLINK "http://www.henricartierbresson.org/" http://www.henricartierbresson.org/